How are largest European companies managing their financial risks?

Total outstanding notional of financial derivatives used by non-financial corporations is USD 27 tn

This huge volume indicates the amount of effort large companies expend on their hedging activities. But is there consensus on the best practice when it comes to corporate risk management?

One of the topics which is often discussed is the fixed-floating proportion of debt. Most companies have to decide on their fixed-floating mix but struggle to find the right answer, because there are so many different aspects which have to be taken into account: historical performance of fixed vs. floating debt, cyclicality of earnings and its correlation with Euribor, projected leverage, tactical aspects, etc.

Ten years ago, it was generally accepted that the floating debt tends to cost less than fixed (or in other words that the forward Euribor curve tends to overestimate the realised interest rates). Since the financial crisis in 2007, the swap curves in major currencies have become much lower and flatter than before. How has this impacted the fixed-floating mix of European corporates? Large international investment grade companies tend to be much more fixed than before because many of them noticed that the swap premium (expected difference between the fixed and floating rates) has reduced tremendously. For example, in the 10-year maturity, historical swap premium in EUR used to be above 3% and at the end of 2019 it is well below 1%. When faced with a much lower (although still positive!) cost of protection against the Euribor, many European companies have decided that this cost is now worth paying and have increased their fixed proportion quite significantly. For example, average fixed proportion of total debt among non-financial CAC 40 companies is 71% and among FTSE 100 companies is 61%.

Of course, fixed-floating mix is just one aspect of the interest-rate decision among many others. Having fixed debt for a year and a day is not the same as having it fixed for 30 years. Therefore, companies have to decide on the optimal duration of their interest rate fixing as well as all the other potential pay-outs: capped, collared, inflation-linked etc. In recent years, proportion of companies using interest rate options has increased for two reasons. First of all, the new accounting standards IFRS9 allow companies to amortise the option pay-out linearly throughout the duration of the hedge, and therefore options are no longer exposing the companies to extra volatility on their income statement. Secondly, many companies have realised that fixing rates does not allow them to benefit from prolonged period of low Euribor and have decided to diversify their pay-outs away from purely fixed or floating.

This is just one example from the second edition of the “Handbook of Corporate Financial Risk Management” which was published by Risk books in September 2019. The handbook is primarily directed to Treasurers, CFOs and Risk managers at non-financial corporations. It contains 43 real-life case studies, based on over 700 client projects over 14 years. The book and its companion website www.corporateriskmanagement.org aim to cover both financial risk management and optimal capital structure and cover the following topics:

 

Articles


Photo from From Bitcoin to Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC)

From Bitcoin to Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC)

In recent months, we have seen the first steps of concerted moves towards CBDCs. This change of attitude is welcome as it complements other private and public initiatives in the world of payments which is innovating at a greater pace than ever.

Read
Photo from Stronger FX Hedging Strategies: a Pandemic Game-changer

Stronger FX Hedging Strategies: a Pandemic Game-changer

As the pandemic continues to throw markets into confusion, forcing corporates to battle against unprecedented volatility, treasury functions have an opportunity, albeit uninvited, to prove their strategic value – especially in relation to FX risk management.

Read
Photo from General Trends in TMS Solutions

General Trends in TMS Solutions

TMS’s have evolved over time and especially in the last couple of years with a huge leap in technologies. Treasurers are investigating how TMS can help in further modernising the finance function in the coming years.

Read
Photo from A Multidisciplinary Approach to Preventing Payment Fraud

A Multidisciplinary Approach to Preventing Payment Fraud

An escalation in fraud and cybercrime activities has been observed in recent months, as cyber attackers have been able to make use of the weaknesses caused by the current health crisis.

Read
Photo from Return on Purpose

Return on Purpose

During the pandemic we have increasingly heard how important it is that companies consider their corporate purpose. Typically, this results in a series of nebulous and hard to define concepts, created by marketing and consultancy firms. Return on Purpose looks at a variety of activities that a company undertakes and identifies individual RoIs for each of them to come up with an overall holistic view.

Read