Impacts of the Armed Conflict in Ukraine on the Management of Energy Hedges on Organized Markets

Volatility, as well as the absolute price levels for some commodities (in particular gas and electricity), had already broken records in the last quarter of 2021. The levels for these two commodities remained high in France and other European markets in the first quarter of 2022, particularly as a result of the armed conflict in Ukraine.

Costs of Intervention on Organized Markets

To manage the price risk on these commodities, many companies, whether they are producers, distributors or users, operate on organized markets such as EEX or ICE. The preference for organized markets for these products, as compared to OTC markets is essentially due to the low credit risk, high liquidity and anonymity they provide. However, the level of volatility and the price level of a product have a strong influence on the amount of the initial deposit or initial margin (IM) that a clearing house requires to allow access to participants in these markets and limit the counterparty risk relating to each transaction as much as possible. These deposits are a cash outflow for those who participate in such organized markets and a cash inflow for the clearing house. They differ from variation margins (VM) which can be incoming or outgoing cash flows depending on the variation in value (unrealized profit or loss) of the position taken by a market participant since its last margin call payment.

The terms “costs of intervention” may seem inappropriate for IMs since it relies to a remunerated deposit that the company will recover at maturity. Nevertheless, for the party who pays it, it is a cash deposit that lasts the time of its participation in the market and might be a structural exposure. On the other hand, such remuneration (currently at very low rates given the market conditions of short-term interest rates) is often very far from the company’s weighted average cost of capital. It would obviously not be the first investment choice of a treasurer. Finally, the periodic review of the amount of IM by the clearing houses – in particular based on the volatility of the underlying position – requires strong short-term cash flexibility from treasurers.

IMs, a Failed Counterparty Risk Management Objective?

While VMs are intended to protect the clearing house and its members from a default by a counterparty on changes in the value of its positions from one day to the next, one of the objectives of IMs is to protect the clearing house and its members from intraday market movements.

However, the amounts of cash mobilized within the framework of the IM to have the right to open positions on the organized markets can be very significant. During recent periods of extreme volatility, they could reach several tens of euros per MWh and represent significant amounts of cash deposits for operators who regularly operate on energy markets. The original purpose of IMs to protect the clearing house from the default of one of its members is generating unwanted effects. An excessive amount of IMs could act as a barrier to entry and prevent a willing participant from having access to organized markets or cause it to close existing positions, due to a lack of sufficient liquidity. The alternative would therefore be either operating on OTC markets and consequently increasing the credit risk present in the deal, or to reduce the outstanding amount of its price risk coverage and incur an increased operational risk compared to its usual mode of operation.

Visible Effects on Net Debt and in the Cash Flow Statement

The growing materiality of these cash impacts for some companies, whether IMs or VMs, requires each exposed company to raise the right questions for their financial disclosures, both in terms of information communicated in relation to net debt as well as the impact of these cash movements in the cash flow statement.

As the conflict between Russia and Ukraine continues to persist, global commodity markets and energy prices continue to fluctuate based on a significant volatility, imposing a very high pressure on the cash exposures of the treasurers.

 

By François Holzman, Global Treasury & Commodities Leader, EY

Association française des trésoriers d'entreprise - AFTE

Articles


Photo from Fear and Anxiety: How to Overcome the ‘Useless’ Varieties

Fear and Anxiety: How to Overcome the ‘Useless’ Varieties

Often the biggest blockers to our success, when we analyse fear and anxiety we realise how nonsensical they are – though very hard it seems to do anything about. Or is it?

Read
Photo from Caught in the Middle?

Caught in the Middle?

Exec and non-exec boards can be great places for learning, sharing and building something together with peers. Often the Treasurer is presenting to these groups, but sometimes it can be challenging in terms of dynamics. If caught up in that ‘traditional’, aggressive corporate boardroom, what can you do?

Read
Photo from How to Stop the Lagging Slovak Economy

How to Stop the Lagging Slovak Economy

A series of panels organised by SAF in recent years have acted as a platform to discuss the economic ambitions of Slovakia, and identify the key indicators hindering the country's economy growth.

Read
Photo from Crisis? What Crisis?

Crisis? What Crisis?

The slowdown in growth has brought with it unprecedented global inflation, causing a tightening of financial conditions and reducing the appetite for risk on the part of traditional financiers. A very complicated future scenario is expected due to the high uncertainty that leads one to think of a possible economic recession.

Read
Photo from EMIR or the Echternach Procession

EMIR or the Echternach Procession

To change EMIR refit would be to take three steps backwards after having taken three steps forwards. Let's not be fooled by good idea at first sight.

Read